JIT finding on Sharif family on Gulf Steel Mills
The Joint Investigation Team in its findings about Gulf Steel Mills has maintained that the story of respondents (Nawaz Sharif and his two sons Hussain Nawaz and Hassan Nawaz), in the light of letter of the Ministry of Justice of UAE and inconsistency in statements of Sharif family, is unauthentic, lacks substance and seems fabricated.
The report said the Ministry of Justice of UAE in response to JIT’s Mutual Legal Assistance, vide their letter No INA 68/2017, dated June 28, 2017, has also certified that share sale agreement 1980 does not exist and, therefore, it is proved beyond doubt that story about sale proceeds worth 12 million Dirham is false and fabricated; it is just a myth and not reality.
The report’s findings also said that two affidavits of Tariq Shafi about seed money (12 million Dirhams) for their business of respondents (especially Avenfield Apartments) cannot be relied upon as evidence. “The evidences were drafted by Barrister Salman Akram Raja on behalf of Tariq Shafi and the witness has not read or understood the affidavit before signing and hence failed to justify contents. The documents are factually incorrect, tampered and misleading,” it said.
The letter from the Ministry of Justice of UAE said that “That share sale agreement of 1980 of Ahli Steel Mills (Gulf Steel Mills) dated 14-04-1980 according to your request does not exist. The available and produced documents, record, circumstantial evidence and discrepancies of Tariq Shafi and respondents also establish that the sale proceeds of Gulf Steel Mills never reached Jeddah, Qatar or UK.”
The letter said that no transaction worth 12 million Dirhams as sale proceedings of 25% shares of Gulf Steel Mills ever took place in the name of Tariq Shafi. The JIT report finds that overall, the inconsistencies in the statements of Sharif family with reference to Gulf Steel Mills and documents obtained from foreign jurisdiction by the JIT through mutual legal assistance conclusively prove that the story of respondents about Gulf Steel Mills is unauthentic, lacks substance and seems fabricated.
The report further states that the respondents have misstated about transportation of scrap machinery of erstwhile Gulf Steel to Jeddah, LC document of transportation of scrap machinery from Dubai to Jeddah unauthentic and fictitious. The report pointed out that from 1978 to 1980, the steel market in Dubai was in boom and the company was earning good profit and why was the company sold when it was earning good profit.
The JIT report in its conclusion about Gulf Steel Mills said the letter by the Ministry of Justice of UAE proves beyond doubt that the documents, record produced by respondents regarding 25 percent share sale agreement are unauthentic, unverified and fake. The JIT in its findings said the Gulf Steel Mills was family business while Tariq Shafi and Muhammad Hussain were Benami owners and Mian Muhammad Sharif was the actual owner. “Being head of the family, Mian Muhammad Sharif used the two Benamidars (an orphan aged 18 years and foreign national) presumably to distance himself and his immediate family member from prosecution.
The findings said that as per information received from the UAE government, the Share Sale Agreement 1980 produced by the respondents under an affidavit in the Supreme Court does not exist. The notarisation of the document has also proved to be fictitious and illegal.
The findings said that stated position of respondents and Tariq Shafi about Gulf Steel Mills and proceedings (12 million Dirhams) is also false, fabricated, inconsistent and factually incorrect and cannot be relied upon. The report observed that Nawaz Sharif, during his address to the nation, stated that in 1980 this factory (Gulf Steel Mills) was sold for 33.37 Dirhams. This is not consistent with either the documents or recorded provided by Respondents. The findings said that Tariq Shafi not only produced false and misleading affidavits in the Supreme Court but is also known to have tainted reputation as he defaulted on loans of BCCI in 1987-88.
Source : The News